2026 NFL Draft Scouting Report: Caleb Downs

Over the last several years, we've seen some elite safety or safety-adjacent slot defenders who come into the draft cycle with a ton of hype, fall due to positional value, and make a huge impact from the jump at the NFL level. Guys like Brian Branch and Malaki Starks come to mind right away as some of the top offerings of this decade who slipped into the 20s, but there's someone in this draft who is potentially better than either of those guys.

Meet Ohio State superstar Caleb Downs: younger brother of Colts wideout Josh Downs, multi-time All-American, and National Champion on last year's Buckeyes squad. A massive transfer portal pull once he left Alabama in the wake of their 2023-24 Rose Bowl defeat, Downs swiftly became as close to the textbook definition of chess piece for Ohio State as you could imagine. His ability to line up everywhere defensively and play at a high level was a huge reason for their success over the last two seasons. Things like his compete level, coverage ability/versatility, instincts, and leadership skills have been brought up frequently, but simply based on what NFL teams have told us through the draft, that may not be enough to draft him high (say top 15). In any case, here's the dossier on No. 2 in red.

Player Bio

Name: Caleb Downs

Jersey: No. 2

Position: Safety

School: Ohio State (By way of Alabama)

Class: Junior 

Height: 6'0" 

Weight: 205 lbs 

Games Watched: vs. Penn State and Texas (2024), vs. Texas, Wisconsin, and Michigan (2025)

Be sure to check out all of our 2026 NFL Draft Coverage!!!

Instincts (14.75/15)

Downs' footbal IQ is off the charts good to begin with, so saying that his natural instincts are perhaps his defining trait isn't all that shocking. His read-react ability especially stands out, and should also come as no suprise this essentially bleeds into his prowess as a zone defender. This wasn't one of the five film games, but watch him here against Miami, reading Carson Beck's eyes, and driving on WR Malachi Toney on a slant to get a fumble forced. (Starks is far right near side at the start here)

Range/Closing Speed (14.5/15)

Downs’ ability to close distance on ball carries (pass or run) is another area where he excels. The only knock was some instances in 2024 where he took some bad angles in between the tackles vs. the run, which led to some (relatively inconsequential) missed plays, but that improved in the 2025 tape, and his ability to close in on pass catchers and affect things at the catch point is tremendous. I'd have no concerns about playing him deep right away, in large part due to his range.

Man Coverage (9/10)

While Down's ability against tight ends in man coverage is going to make him uber valuable in the NFL, and does the heavy lifting with the score here, he definitely has more experience in zone, and that's where his money will ultimately be made. Certainly not a weakness, though. Hard to overstate the potential of him in a tight end eraser in man coverage if he can bulk up just a tad, though. I thought he was tremendous in coverage against Tyler Warren in the 2024 Penn State game when he was tasked with going against him.

Zone Coverage (9.75/10)

Downs is an elite zone defender who comes into the NFL with a slew of high-end reps playing as the centerman in cover three, in two shell looks, and in the middle of third. The best compliment I can give Downs is that much of his film was boring, since offenses clearly respected him enough to stay away, but he certainly demonstrated the ability to pass guys off, bail out on time, and anticipating things around him while staying locked in on the QB's eyes.

Ball Skills (8.75/10)

With 10 career PBUs and six interceptions (two in each season), Downs doesn't have the most prolific ball production resume. Can't fault him for the fact that he wasn't thrown at a great deal, but it's something to note. That said, Downs also forced a pair of fumbles in the Cotton Bowl recently against The U. Unfortunately for Ohio State, neither resulted in a turnover.

Change of Direction (9.25/10)

Downs is pretty fluid in his lower half and moves fundamentally well, which showed up when he was playing deep. His ability to trigger downhill working north/south or transferring from east/west closer to the line also popped out.

Tackling/Run Support (8.75/10)

He's not exactly Kyle Hamilton or Derwin James from a size standpoint, but Downs is more than a willing participant against the run, which isn't a big surprise given his usage in the box, and he certainly has a knack for making some plays in the run game, cemented by a three-play stretch vs. Wisconsin where he made three consecutive run stops in a row.

On top of just wanting to see him wrap up just a bit better (he admitedly has good instincts on when to go low most of the time), I also have slight concerns about how well Downs will hold up vs. NFL pass catchers blocking out in space since that was a slight problem (more so in the 2024 film). Getting him up to around 210-215 lbs should certainly help out. Lastly, for whatever it's worth, Downs has a good knack for shoestring takedowns from behind. By my count, he had three in these five games, one of which for sure saved a touchdown.

Versatility (9.75/10)

Box defender, slot defender, single high, two shell safety, punt returner, DB blitzer, hell, Downs even has a (very) limited amount of snaps out on the boundary this year according to PFF. His best usage right away would be in the box, two shell looks, and as the single high in cover three defenses, but he's a legit impact player in a lot of different roles.

Athleticism (9/10)

I wouldn't put Downs on the level of an athlete such as Nick Emmanwori of last year's class, and he's someone who I would like to see test at the combine to know just how athletic he is, but there's nothing that I saw that would indicate to me Downs isn't a fantastic athlete. Beyond just the fact that he has a couple of dynamite punt touchdowns on his resume, he was also a two-way player in high school (running back), in addition to playing basketball and baseball before jumping to Alabama.

Player Summary

There are "don't overthink it" prospects, and then there's Caleb Downs. Elite leadership, communication, and football IQ skills for a safety who is as fearless a swift army knife as he is, albeit a bit undersized, can add so much to any defense in the league. Nothing I saw in these five games, or in passing while watching Ohio State this year, dissuades me from a long-held opinion that he’s the best player in this draft, regardless of position. Again, this is the most "don't overthink it" guy in this class, which is naturally why he'll slip out of the top 20, much like Malaki Starks did a year ago. But if someone in the top 15 wants to be smart for a change, you're getting an unbelievable football player that'll make you better on day one.

Rookie Projections: DROY Contender

Third-Year Projection: All-Pro Caliber Player

Final Grade (93.5/100): Top-10 Talent

Main Image via